English 1A
Peaches Henry, believes that the novel Huckleberry Finn, should not be require to read, but should be a choice. Because not everyone are comfortable by the way that this novel is written and how the language is being used in the story. There are some arguments that Henry is trying to make, and thinks that if this novel should be removed or not and if not then it should be taught when youÕre in high school and college and not earlier. Because of how the brain works in some ages, some are more mature than others. And some others are just being a kid and donÕt want to grow up and using the ÒnÓ word like its funny or some kind of a game, or use it as name calling. And the reason for this novel to be removed is because of how the language is in this story that shouldnÕt be out for people to read and itÕs not right for a small age to read because of how little they understands the word.
I agree that this book should be taught in high school and college because of how the language is being used and how hard it is to understand how the story goes. Also if this novel were to be taught it should be in high school, I think it should be in an AP English class because I believe people that take AP classes have a very clear understanding mind, because AP classes are getting the students ready for college. I believe in colleges they would have to read a lot of books or novels that are a lot like Huckleberry Finn, if not it might be something sampler. Also teaching this book in college is also better then teaching in an elementary school or middle school because elementary and middle school students are not mature enough to learn these kind of word in a book or novel. And whatever they hear they will think itÕs ok to use because other people is saying it as well. Kids have no self control of what they are doing or saying. For example: Henry had shared her experience and how it made her feel angry when her classmate read the ÒnÓ word out loud. This kind of experiences doesnÕt just happen with her. These experiences could also happen with anyone, also when people that donÕt know what it means because they came from another country. For example: when I came back to the US from Hong Kong when I was young, I didnÕt know what the ÒnÓ word means and the teacher didnÕt explain it and I remembered I said that word and I almost got myself beat but thank god for my friend that helped me out and telling me what it meant and not to say it anymore. After that experience I believe the teacher should explain, what it means also how uncomfortable it is to some other students. I agree that this book should be taught only if youÕre a high school student that is a senior and in an AP class or in college. Because their mind and critical thinking are much more mature than others. ÒSchool officials and parents clash over the schoolÕs right to intellectual freedom and the parentsÕ right to protect their children from perceived racism. (p 386)Ó. É a.
The part where I disagree with her is when she thinks (for a little while) that this book should be removed from the board of education. Because this novel can teach people many things by how the story goes. Even though it uses a lot of the ÒnÓ word and when people read this novel might feel uncomfortable, but some other people see it as a lighthearted adventure. Many people can learn things from this novel because there are many historical things that are goes on that shows in Huckleberry Finn, for example: it shows how hard and how much pain they had to go though in order to get to where they have right now, their freedom. They also had to do many things to keep themselves alive. This novel shows a lot of things that history class only covers a little. I think Mark Twain wrote it like so was not trying to be racists but to try to show people the history behind it all of how it starts to how it ends. Because he was there when it was going on till it ends, even though it was over when it wrote it, it doesnÕt mean it has never happened before. I believe that was the reason why Mark Twain wrote this novel like this.
This novel should read with super visionÕs when is taught to little kids or premature teens. Because parents should have the control of what their children is doing or saying. And if theyÕre uncomfortable with it, they should change it in to something that is more comfortable for them to read. Having a super vision like a parent or a teacher to explain what thing means and what not to copy from what they have seen form TVÕs, read or hear from other people. Also to respect each other, even though things are taught by teachers it does not mean itÕs ok for students to use it outside of class or to use it to call other student names. If this novel is going to be taught in elementary and middle school kids the teachers should explain clearly and not to offend other students also make it as an options and not a requirement to read this novel because not everyone are comfortable to read this. Also the teachers and parents should have self control of their students and children.
This novel has many reasons for being removed and it also have reasons for keeping it for greater education. Reasons for being removed is that there are many difficult language that is hard to understand but the main reason for being removed is the ÒnÓ word that keeps on showing in every page, that never takes a break. Also of how uncomfortable it makes people feel when theyÕre reading this novel. Also having this novel read in a young age when theyÕre still in elementary school and middle school is really unsafe because at their age they are not mature enough to understand such difficult languages. Reasons for keeping it is that It is a great novel also a great way to understand the history and there are many things that goes on in this novel not just racism but satire as well as many other things. Many people see this as racism and a few people can see some satire but this novel also have some historical things that goes on. Reasons for this novel to be kept is that it shows the world that history of anyone in any racistis important to know and understand.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

1.I think your thesis is children won't allow to read the book because how hard to understand the word.
ReplyDelete2.You have good example about yourself. You can try to connect the article, that will give you more evidence.
3.I know it is your rough, so you will give more what's your thought in your finally paper.
4.I was not sure how you could write a counter claim so this part of the peer review probably would not apply.
5.I think you have nice beginning. You can giving more examples about your thought.
6.Does not apply to your paper.
7.I think that you have good start.
good job. this seems like a hard topic to write about and you have done great. clear thesis.
ReplyDelete